Thoughts from Parshas Devarim/Shabbas Chazon
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/78328/78328a6751843e4fa0ac044c697117b92789faec" alt=""
The question has always come up, the first bais hamikdash was destroyed because of avoda zara, shfichas damim and gilui arayos. The big three. That makes sense. That churban only lasted 70 years. The second bais hamikdash was destroyed because of sinas chinam almost TWO THOUSAND years ago. The fact that sinas chinam was reason enough to destroy the bais hamikdash is pretty shocking, but enough to keep us in galus for two thousand years, is mind boggling.
Years ago I spent a shabbos with an african american ger tzedek. He is a truly amazing person. I hardly slept that shabbos, I was tied to his every word to soak up what he had to say. At one point, he turns to me, and out of nowhere, mentions the question I just raised. He said, he couldn't understand it, until a few years prior. He went on to say that he is an extremely calm, patient and mild mannered person. It takes a lot to get him angry, but there is one thing that gets under his skin and causes him to erupt more than anything else. It's when his kids are fighting with each other, particularly for no good reason. I think any parent with more than one child or any child that had at least one sibling can relate. He looks at me, and says, that's what sinas chinam is to Hashem. It's two of his children fighting for no real reason. I just stood there in awe. So simple, so brilliant.
Good Shabbos!
10 Comments:
Funny I was just listening to a torah tape on onaas devarim and it said that the way not to do this sin is to put respect into relationships which will make people judge less and talk badly less. Anyway, thank you that was a very nice dvar torah. Sounds like an amazing person, glad you got to have that experience with him. It's good to soak things up:).
" It's two of his children fighting for no real reason. I just stood there in awe. "
Who wouldn't? Parhaps his whole journey to Judaism was to say thoses words to you, and for you to relate them on your blog. "Gevalt, you never know."
Sometimes I hear or read about bashing on blogs and know that Hashem is crying.
beautiful.
i was wondering, whats the equivalent of the galut in your analogy with the fighting children? splitting them up and putting them in seperate corners/rooms?
how long does that need to last?? 2000 years seems like a really long time..
(anyone ever watch that malcolm in the middle episode when dewy gets sent to the corner, and the parents forget him and go to sleep and find him there in the morning, still standing, sleeping in the corner :)
not that im comparing, g-d forbid.. but it reminded me... :)
sometimes i wonder what exactly sinas chinom is..
i sense that part of what it may mean is
holding a grudge needlessly
being judgemental
coveting and not fargining..
Nice explanation...
I've always understood the reason being...that as long as theres sinas chinam..then the goal of the geulah..namely perfection and peace is being directly blocked...
other sins can be dealt with and punishment can wipe away the damage..
to kids who are fighting I always say "stop behaving like grown ups"!
It works
I think Sinaas chinum is a derivative of jealousy... great devar torah... really hits the spot at this time of year! I also second what Neil Harris said....
when you write it out so clearly I ralize, hey, why are we waiting so much longer for the 3rd??? makes no sense. I guess we should all take upon ourselves to be that much nicer to eachother in order to bring the geulah once and for all. I have a question, does that mean we have to be nice to the goyin as well or is this just pertaining to jews? crazy question but curious
That's a great story. Waiting for more. » » »
Pragmatician is a genius!!!
Post a Comment
<< Home