Tuesday, August 01, 2006

Al Aileh Ani Bochiya

After the Bais Hamikdash was destroyed, the gemara tells us that the chachamim were so distraught over the loss of the bais hamikdash that they wanted to prohibit the eating of meat and the drinking of wine. The gemara is not discussing the nine days, the chachamim wanted to prohibit meat and wine until mashiach came. Luckily for us, one of the tannaim came with an argument that caused them to re-think it, but the original thought was there.
Where is that passion today? Where is that longing for the bais hamikdash and the geula?
You might say, well, that was when the loss was still fresh in their minds, and to some degree that's true. In sefer Ezra it's written, that the day of the dedication of the second bais hamikdash was a day of great joy and crying. The younger generation was thrilled and overjoyed, but the older generation that lived to see the first bais hamikdash and saw and recognized that the second was not on the same level of the first, they cried.
Rav Hutner once said, the difference between Yom Kippur and Tisha B'Av is that on Yom Kippur, ver daft essen (who needs to eat) and on Tisha B'Av, ver ken essen (who can bring themselves to eat). Rav Hutner didn't live that long ago. He was from the previous generation, the 20th century, and yet he felt it. Why don't we?
There is a machlokes as to whether or not Tisha B'Av was observed as a fast day during the time when the second bais hamikdash was standing. The consensus seems to be that they did indeed fast on Tisha B'Av. HaRav Soloveitchik says that it was a day of tefila being that it was a day destined for tragedy, even though the bais hamikdash had been rebuilt, it was important to pray and cry to prevent future tragedies as well. As I heard Rabbi Moshe Weinberger say, anyone that survived the Holocaust is eternally scarred and every event and decision in their life is influenced by those experiences.
Where is that emotion? What happened to us to make us so stone cold?
Most people that I observe look for the easy ways out, the kulos not the chumros. You can listen to music, as long as it's not live. You can take a shower because you take one every day. You can shave because you go to work. You can eat meat because you went to a siyum. You can go swimming because it's really hot. The list of rationalizations are endless. I am not chas v'shalom disputing the kulos that people have. If you go to a siyum you can eat meat, etc., I'm not denying that, my point is, why is that the angle we look for? Why is it that most people look to daven in the shul that says the shortest kinus? I was in one shul which starts at 8 AM and has over a hundred mispallelim, and by chatzos when they finish, they barely have a minyan. Where is everybody rushing off to? Working on Tisha B'Av, hmmmm, of course, it helps pass the day.
We are taught that Kol Hamisabel al Yerushalayim Roeh Bnechemasa. How many of us are truly misabel? How many of us sleep on the floor, as is brought in chazal? Why don't we try, for one day a year to seek out the chumros not the kulos? Our job is to take the KINUT and turn it into a TIKUN. If we do that, may we all merit to see the building of the third bais hamikdash, bimheira b'yamaynu, amein!

13 Comments:

Blogger socialworker/frustrated mom said...

Nice pic, very cool. It is very hard to really cry or feel the void of not having the mikdash. Sometimes it helps if we think of our sorrows to get ourselves in the somber mood and then try to transfer the feelings to the churban. Just a thought. Very nice ideas and expressions thanks.

August 01, 2006 10:06 AM  
Blogger Neil Harris said...

Great posting. Rav Hutner, the Rav, and Rav Weinberger. Awesome. Everything you said is correct. The truth is that we have to imagine what we've lost. It's not like losing your wallet or your keys. We've lost a part of our own potential. Without a true home for HKBH we are not whole.

August 01, 2006 10:18 AM  
Blogger FrumGirl said...

I think that part of the sadness of golus is that most of us cannot connect to it like that. We are so many generations removed from knowing what we are missing.... Your passion for this is inspiring... thank you for a great post!

August 01, 2006 12:44 PM  
Blogger chaverah said...

I do agree that time and the mind forgets as we get further away from something. But that is our defense mechanism to deal with different issues. So yes, it is upsetting that we can not relate to those who experienced the churban. However if we really felt the same way they did we could not live normal lives. We would have this horrible feeling of longing and could not function properly. So we need to thank god that the mind forgets. Dont you agree?

August 01, 2006 3:04 PM  
Blogger anonym00kie said...

beautifully said, and i really like chaverahs comment too..
i also feel that guilt sometimes, but the alternative wouldnt be liveable..im usually not big on chumras, but youre right, when something is for such a short period and so important i think its worth putting in a little extra effort..

August 01, 2006 6:19 PM  
Blogger the only way i know said...

AFI
I don't know what to say - this was such a great post - R A Miller had this thing printed - or someone printed in his name - a list of things to do each day - you hang it on the wall - one of the things is to sit on the floor for one second and remember yerushalayim - it's a tiny thing - but done every day - it builds the feeling you're describing...
fast well.

August 01, 2006 6:47 PM  
Blogger David_on_the_Lake said...

Its true...
I do have to tell you..I feel my shoresh haneshoma is in tisha b'av..more than all the other yomim tovim..
I find it easier to cry than to dance...

August 01, 2006 10:31 PM  
Blogger Pragmatician said...

Good post.
About the 'abusive' use of kulos I believe the problem is that refraining from music, meat etc.. is not making us more aware of the lack of our own Bayis Hamikdosh.

They're just inconveniences.
If we were taught what the Bayis Hmikdahs was, what is meant, what position it had for Jews when it was still standing, how close were able to get to H'Ashem, then the sadness and miss would kick in, not because there’s delicious Pizza in the oven instead of roaster chicken.

August 02, 2006 5:15 AM  
Blogger A Frum Idealist said...

I wonder if there's a connection between the Aileh that I mentioned in my previous post and the Aileh in this one.... hmmmmm.

August 02, 2006 12:43 PM  
Blogger smb said...

So true and sad, we are so removed, we don't feel it anymore. but we can still try. thanks

August 02, 2006 1:08 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

You spoke about Tefila ? : http://www.torah-box.com/cours/tefila-la-priere,32/

August 17, 2006 11:00 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Cool blog, interesting information... Keep it UP Accept credit cards free merchant account digital printing breast implants and lifts What is fioricet hydrochloride Celexa truth and side effects Depression treatments effective antidepressant therapy How to use ice cream makers paintball franchises valium for febrile seizure

February 21, 2007 8:50 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Very nice site! 1969 pontiac lemans sport Stationery supplies laws on short term disability insurance discontinued http://www.eczema-suffer.info Car before you buy Nova scotia dialup internet access Discount light truck tires kumho http://www.uk-cialis-sales.info/Doctors-who-prescribe-propecia-in-hawaii.html Imitrex generic Mac pdas read reviews and compare Ambien mail order drug stores Wireless internet pdas peugeot cycle Salvage used parts volvo rear tail light 1997 mazda 626 lx flat screen t v mercedes diesel tuners turbo peugeot eu

March 06, 2007 5:05 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home